[35] (10) Make a list of the songs on the listening list in which
Pink Floyd uses the image of a dog. How many different ways can these
images be interpreted? How many of them might refer specifically
to Roger?
[36] (10) Make a list of the songs on the listening list in which
Pink Floyd uses the image "stone". Do they all refer to the same
concept?
[37] (10) Make a list of words in the Pink Floyd "lexicon" (other
than the 2 above) that are used repeatedly in many of their songs.
See how many different ways those terms have been used, and speculate on
how the meanings changed over the years.
[38] (10) [A] Research the life of another musician who,
like Syd Barrett, forayed into drugs in search of inspiration for his music,
but became hopelessly lost.
[39] (3) [A] Who is Spike Jones, and how does he relate to Pink
Floyd?
PRE-"PIPER" QUESTIONS (Answer Value) {Either 40 or
42 are required, but not both}{Ditto with 44 & 45}
*[40] (20) [L] Compare Arnold Layne to the characteristics
of the Pink Floyd sound that are listed on the Characteristics
page. What evidence can you find in that tune of the qualities that
would later come to define Pink Floyd?
[41] (3) [A] Of what crime(s) might Arnold Layne have been guilty?
*[42] (20) [L] Compare See Emily Play to the characteristics
of the Pink Floyd sound that are listed on the Characteristics
page. What evidence can you find in that tune of the qualities that
would later come to define Pink Floyd?
[43] (4) [A] What might a psychiatrist diagnose as Emily's problems?
*[44] (10) [L] Compare and contrast the live and studio versions
of Careful With That Axe, Eugene.
*[45] (20) [A][L] As you listen to Careful With That Axe,
Eugene use a blank sheet of paper to record your visual and verbal
thoughts. Doodle, draw, or write down images that pop into your head,
and see what recurring themes you come up with. (It is probably best
to do this the first time you listen to the song, as later listenings
will be "colored" by your experience.)
"PIPER" QUESTIONS (Answer Value)
[46] (7) [A] In what context does Kenneth Grahame use the phrase "Piper
at the Gates of Dawn" in Wind in the Willows? How do you think
it applies here? Do any modern artists use such childhood images
in their songs?
[47] (12) [A] [L] Listen to another song from 1967, and tell
how it is similar to and different from one of the songs on this album.
Choose a song that has some similarities; it wouldn't be fair to
compare Lucifer Sam with the #1 song of that year, To Sir With
Love.
[48] (5) [A] [L] Describe how any one song on SERGEANT
PEPPER'S LONELY HEARTS CLUB BAND is similar in some way (or several)
with a song on this album.
*[49] (20) [A] Randomly choose a letter of the alphabet.
Turn to that letter in the dictionary, and pick out 30 "interesting" words
(if possible, see if you can fit them into a theme).
Now, think of words that rhyme with 15 of the ones you've chosen (if you
didn't use a theme with the first group, try using one with this group).
Restructure these words into a poem (don't worry if it doesn't seem to
make much sense). Now, compare your poem to the one that makes up
the words to Astronomy Domine. Does this put any ideas into
your head?
[50] (5) [L] What similarities and differences do you find between
the live and studio versions of Astronomy Domine?
[51] (8) [L] As you listen to Pow R Toc H, use a blank
sheet of paper to record your visual and verbal thoughts. Doodle,
draw, or write down images that pop into your head, and see what recurring
themes you come up with.
[52] (5) [L] Find a way to connect Take Up Thy Stethoscope
and Walk with any other song written later by Roger Waters.
[53] (15) [L][A] Listen to Interstellar Overdrive three
times, each time recording your impressions and observations. Listen
once with all the balance on the Left ear, once with all the balance on
the Right ear, and once with the balance set evenly. Having done
all of this, do your observations lend credence to theory that the song
is simply two "jam" tracks played simultaneously?
[54] (10) [L] Draw a musical "map" that shows the pattern followed
by Interstellar Overdrive.
[55] (5) Who, or what, (specifically) is Grimble Gromble?
(In other words, find out where Syd found him.)
[56] (5) Look at the 5 things Syd says he has "got" in the song
Bike.
Is there any connecting theme among them? Do they have anything to
do with his girlfriend in the song? What special emphasis might we
put on the last three sentences?
"SAUCERFUL" QUESTIONS (Answer Value)
*[57] (15) [L] Identify the characteristics of the Pink Floyd
sound that are evident in Let There Be More Light.
[58] (6) [L][A] Identify the obscure people, places, events,
and things mentioned in Let There Be More Light.
[59] (5) [L][A] How does William Burrows use the phrase "Set
the controls for the heart of the sun"? Does the song connect in
any way with the literature? Is the song some sort of homage to Burrows?
"MORE" QUESTIONS (Answer Value)
[60] (5) [L] Use what you know about the characteristics of
"Punk" music to compare to The Nile Song. By those qualities,
would this piece qualify as "punk"?
[61] (5) [L] What, do you think, the Nile River has to do with
anything in the The Nile Song or the movie "More"?
[62] (10)[A] [L] As you listen to the
More Theme, use
a blank sheet of paper to record your visual and verbal thoughts.
Doodle, draw, or write down images that pop into your head, and see what
recurring themes you come up with.
[63] (5) [L] Compare and contrast The Nile Song with
Ibiza
Bar.
[64] (4) [L] What ideas might the band have learned from
Pow
R Toc H that they applied to Cirrus Minor?
[65] (3) [L] What, do you believe, is the "inner meaning" of
the words to Cirrus Minor?
[66] (3) [L] What does the fictional "character" in the song
Ibiza
Bar ask for? What does he most want out of "life"?
"ATOM HEART" QUESTIONS (Answer Value) {Only 67 or
68 is required. Not both}
*[67] (10) [A] [L] As you listen to Atom Heart Mother,
think about the inherent problems in trying to fit an orchestra into a
rock and roll framework. Jot down your ideas.
*[68] (20) [A] [L] As you listen to Atom Heart Mother,
use a piece of blank paper to doodle pictures or jot down words and images
that come into your mind. Think about the themes that might be present.
[69] (15) [A] Imagine that you had written the lyrics to If.
Take the first part of each line ("If I were a _____"), then rewrite the
second half to express your own personality and beliefs.
[70] (5) [L] In the song If, what do you think was Roger's
purpose in using the repetition of lyrical and musical phrases?
[71] (8) [A] [L] In Fat Old Sun, Dave sings about
the feeling he gets at the end of the day. Find another song in which
an artist records his images of sundown, and compare them to Dave's.
How do they compare to yours?
[72] (20) [A] [L] Research the work of another rock band
who tried to incorporate their music into an orchestral presentation.
(This does not include those cheesy THE PHILHARMONIC PLAYS
NINE INCH NAILS HITS collections.) How successful were they?
What difficulties did they seem to run into? Were the results more
or less listenable than Pink Floyd's?
[73] (3) What is the origin of the title of this album?
[74] (5) [A] Who is Don Ellis, and how might he be connected
to the ideas in this album?
"MEDDLE" QUESTIONS
*[75] (20) [A] [L] Find another 16-Track recording done in 1971.
Compare the use of the multiple tracks on that recording with anything
on this album. Discuss whether Pink Floyd was as advanced in their
use of this technology as everyone seems to think.
[76] (5) [L] Would it be possible to play One of These Days
without the use of echo electronics? If you know nothing about the
technique required to play bass guitar, ask someone who does.
[77] (5) [L] Is Pillow of Winds underrated, or just a
rather unimportant song?
[78] (10) [A][L] Find the lyrics to the song
You'll Never
Walk Alone. Compare them to the lyrics in Fearless.
What are the similarities? Why do you think Pink Floyd chose this
particular ambient sound for this song?
*[79] (20) [A][L] Take a blank sheet of paper to draw or write
on as you listen to Echoes. Draw images that pop into your
mind, or write, free-association style, the words that you think of as
you listen.
[80] (8) Look carefully at the lyrics to Echoes.
I often feel that there are three distinct images being described here.
Reflect upon the meanings you find in these lyrics. (No fair using
what I wrote at the bottom of the MEDDLE review.)
[81] (10) Debate my interpretation of the lyrics to
Echoes.
(Now you'll have to look at the bottom of that page.)
"DARK SIDE" QUESTIONS {At least 3 are required from this album}
[82] (10) [L] Evaluate my friend Dan Ondrusek's contention that
Time
has one of the most important sets of lyrics in Rock music history.
[83] (20) [A] [L] Draw or jot down images and ideas that go
through your mind as you listen to The Great Gig in the Sky.
What is the literal meaning of this song title?
[84] (15) [A] [L] Find any other Rock song like
Money,
the majority of which is in something other than 4/4 or Cut time.
To what effect did that band use the unusual time signature? Why
do so few bands try this technique?
[85] (15) [A] [L] What statements about war and poverty do the
lyrics to Us and Them really make? Why do you suppose the
band used such unusual music to carry this idea? Compare this to
Edwin Starr's recording of War.
[86] (10) [L] As you listen to the song Any Colour You Like,
see if you can advance any theories about where the title came from.
[87] (10) [A] Make a list of all the inappropriately-used Psychological
terms in the song Brain Damage (there's one now!). Why do
people so often use professional jargon incorrectly? What effect
does it have in the case of this song?
[88] (10) Compare and contrast the way repetition is used in
Eclipse
with the way it is used in Dogs. What similarities and differences
do you find?
[89] (20) [A] [L] See if you can figure out the chord patterns
to the songs on this album. Which patterns are most frequently repeated?
How does this tie the album together? Does it make it boring?
Does it set a certain ambiance?
[90] (20) [A] Evaluate the applicability of the
Wizard of
Oz connection with this album by playing it along with the movie.
There are numerous websites that discuss the point at which you must start
the music in order to find the connections. Try not to be influenced
by the opinions of those writers. Is there any possibility that there
is anything more than coincidence at work?
[91] (20) [A] Find another recording in which a band explores
the concept of insanity. How are their interpretations different
than those of Pink Floyd? Whose musical "picture" is more accurate
or effecting?
[92] (10) [A] [L] Listen to any recording by the Alan Parsons
Project. Can you find any elements of similarity between that recording
and the work he did on this album?
"WISH YOU WERE HERE" QUESTIONS {At least two from this album
are required.}
[93] (20) [A] [L] Make a musical "map" that shows where the
parts of Shine On, You Crazy Diamond begin, and the musical "idea"
that is communicated in each part.
[94] (20) [A] Make a list of the lyric phrases in Shine On,
You Crazy Diamond that refer to Syd Barrett, and tell what each one
of them means.
[95] (15) According to the lyrics of Welcome to the Machine,
how do people view what it's like to be a rock star? Compare this
to the lyrics of Have a Cigar, which are supposed to be sung by
a recording company executive. How does the reality differ from the
romantic image? Is it really like being in a machine? Would
you like to be a part of that machine?
[96] (15) Make a +/- list of images evoked by the lyrics of
Wish
You Were Here. Looking at them altogether, what themes do you
recognize?
"ANIMALS" QUESTIONS
[97] (10) [L] As you listen to the two parts of Pigs on the
Wing, sandwiched as they are around the vituperative songs in the middle
of the album, do the intentions take on different aspects from what the
lyrics try to convey?
*[98] (15) Make a list of the negative cliches that Roger uses
pertaining to Dogs. How does he apply those images to businessmen?
Add to this a list of negative images he evokes of businessmen. How
do those images change when we view them as dogs instead of human beings?
[99] (5) I get the feeling that the first four lines of the
third section of Dogs are intended to be spoken by the dog,
instead of about him. If I'm right, how does that change the overall
intent of the song?
[100] (5) What do the Pigs (3 Different Ones) have in
common? How are they different?
[101] (3) What is the meaning behind the phrase "you're nearly
a treat, but you're really a cry."?
[102] (10) [A] Find some reliable information on the actual history
of Mary Whitehouse.
[103] (5) Make a list of the cliches about Sheep that
Roger uses. How does he apply these to human beings? Why does
he allow them to step out of character at the end?
[104] (10) [A] Compare the way Roger anthropomorphosizes the
3 animals on this album with the way George Orwell does in his book
Animal
Farm.
"THE WALL" QUESTIONS
*[105] (15) [L] What lyric changes did Roger Waters make between
In
the Flesh? and In the Flesh! ? What effect do those changes
cause? What do those changes indicate about the meaning of the punctuation
change? Is there any significant change in the music to go along
with those lyric changes?
*[106] (10) [L] As you listen to Outside the Wall, does
it evoke any feelings for you of a time when you have experienced this
frustration? In other words, have you ever tried very hard to help
someone who kept you at a distance by shutting you out beyond their protective
wall? Have you ever shut someone else out in this fashion?
Did you consider how they might have felt about being excluded in this
way?
*[107] (20) [L] As you listen to the songs on the Listening
List that fit Theme #3, think about the way the musical phrase appears.
How does this musical phrase create a certain feeling? Write out
how the theme sounds.
[108] (10) [L] As you listen to the songs that fit Theme #3,
look at the events that have caused the character to build his "wall".
Relate how, in your life, you have either avoided or been effected by the
same forces he describes as being at work destroying
his life.
[109] (5) How many different people is Roger speaking to in
Hey,
You, and who are they?
[110] (10) In Nobody Home "Pink" tries to impress us with
all the things he's got. Make a list of what these things are, and
what they represent. Then evaluate what he really has.
Why do you think he is trying to impress us? What would he really
like to have?
[111] (10) [L] What analogies can you draw about how being in
a touring Rock and Roll band is somewhat like going to war? As you
listen to Bring the Boys Back Home, do you think Roger was thinking
of any of the same analogies?
"FINAL CUT" QUESTIONS
[112] (5) [L] In what ways are the post war dream and
your
possible pasts like songs from THE WALL?
[113] (5) What really was the post-war dream? Have
we realized any of it? Have we realized the most important parts
of it?
[114] (5) [L] What impressions of veterans does Roger give by
his lyrics and musical images in the songs one of the few, and
the
hero's return?
[115] (5) What exactly did the gunner dream? In what ways
do you share the gunners dream?
*[116] (20) [L] As you listen to the final cut imagine
that Roger is really saying goodbye to his bandmates. Given the images
in this song, what sort of person is Roger Waters exactly?
What might the final cut have been?
[117] (10) What analogies can you draw about how being in a
touring Rock and Roll band is somewhat like going to war? As you
listen to songs from this album, do you think Roger was thinking of any
of the same analogies?
"MOMENTARY LAPSE" QUESTIONS {One of these is required.}
[118] (10) Make a list of the various ways the word "Fly" might
be interpreted. Then, as you listen to Learning to Fly, see
how many of those are used.
[119] (10) [L] As you listen to Dogs of War see if you
can make an objective list of reasons why this song is regularly voted
the "worst Pink Floyd song ever".
[120] (10) Is there any hidden message in On The Turning
Away? What is the message? Based on the feelings
he expresses here, are you in "danger" of turning away?
[121] (15) [A] Write out the storyline of the film described
in Yet Another Movie. Can you think of any film that contains
many of these elements? How does it tie in with
Round and Around?
[122] (10) What is the character in Sorrow sorrowful
about? Have you ever felt that sort of sorrow? Why does he
use the phrase "sweet smell" to describe sorrow?
"DIVISION BELL" QUESTIONS
[123] (10) [A] [L] As you listen to Cluster 1, use a blank
sheet of paper to record your visual or verbal images. What do you
think the song "means"? How does this song compare with others
for which you have done this sort of exercise?
*[124] (15) Compare What Do You Want From Me? to the
two parts of In the Flesh!/? What was Dave's message to his
audience and to Roger by composing this piece? How are Dave's images
different from Roger's?
*[125] (10) What is the literal meaning of the phrase "poles
apart"? To what does that phrase allude? In the song
Poles
Apart how does Dave explore his relationship with Roger? What
message is he sending to us?
[126] (10) If, in fact, DIVISION BELL represents
Dave and the band's attempt to be Coming Back to Life, how does
this song advance their goal? Is it convincing that they've accomplished
what they set out to do? What is symbolized by "staring straight
into the shining sun"?
[127] (10) [A] Why might the band have chosen Stephen Hawking
to speak the narration of Keep Talking? Might some people
consider this to be exploitation? Research Mr. Kurzweil and the company
he created. How does he figure into this story?
*[128] (30) [L] What do you think of the way in which the division
bell is used in High Hopes? What effect does it have to hear
the bell ringing in a certain rhythm, then have the song come in on the
off-beat? What other Pink Floyd songs use similar effects?
What in the world do the lyrics have to do with the title? What are/were
they hoping for? Was there any reason to believe from the lyrics
that this would be the last Pink Floyd song ever?